The boots are to replace my cheap "No Boundaries" ones I bought years ago. I loved these boots because the chunky heel/platform allowed me to wear regular length jeans without the bottoms dragging on the ground. I don't like petite jeans because the rise is usually smaller- & Hoozey's got "back" & thighs. LOL Alas last year, I developed a crack in the one sole-- so thus my quest for a new pair of boots.
One of my daughter's favorite pairs of heels are by Naturalizer so I decided to look there first. I liked the look of the "Giddy" boot for a couple of reasons. #1 it's not a tall boot- along with "back" & thighs, I have huge calves-- I blame my flat feet on this condition. I can NOT fit into boots that go much above the ankle. Case in point I tried on rain boots one day with daughter and she was shocked that my calf BARELY fit into them. I also like that the toe is somewhat rounded. I feel like my feet are a bit large (size 8) for my 5'2" stature so I tend to steer away from super pointy shoes/boots. I love that they are leather and well worth the $85 purchase price (20% sale.)
While browsing through the Naturalizer shoes/boots I came across the "Carnivale" style of shoes. I couldn't resist and I am now thinking that these will get more wear than the boots. I love the little "collars" at the top. The heel heights are identical to the boots- 2 & 3/4 inches with a fairly chunky heel so plenty of support. I think they will look darling with jeans but could also see these with sheath dress and tights. I prefer this brown color to the boots redder brown. I think these were about $65 with 20% discount so pretty reasonable for leather shoes. I think they will be a good "price per wear" item in my wardrobe.